Carbon Atoms with Formal Charges — Question 10

Section 2-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 349–350

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Reverse-engineer a carbon electron inventory

A proposed ordinary closed-shell carbon site X has bond-order sum four. Enforce the octet rule.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Determine how many nonbonding electrons X may have.

  2. Find its formal charge.

  3. A draft assigns X a -1 charge without changing any bonds. Explain why that cannot describe an octet carbon.

Question 10 - Solution

Reverse-engineer a carbon electron inventory

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Four bond orders already place eight electrons around X, leaving no room for a lone pair under the octet rule.

(b)

With zero nonbonding electrons, FC=4−4=0\mathrm{FC}=4-4=0.

(c)

To obtain -1 at bond-order sum four requires one nonbonding electron, giving nine surrounding electrons and an open shell. It is incompatible with the specified ordinary closed-shell octet carbon.