Carbocation Rearrangements — Question 9

Section 6-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 1387–1388

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Reject a remote jump disguised as one 1,2-shift

A proposal transfers H directly from C4 to C2 and calls it a single 1,2-hydride shift.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Are the donating C4 and accepting C2 adjacent?

  2. Give a formal sequence of neighboring hydride shifts that relocates the cation from C2 to C4.

  3. Does identifying a permissible sequence prove it occurs preferentially?

Question 9 - Solution

Reject a remote jump disguised as one 1,2-shift

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. C3 lies between them, so the proposed remote transfer is not one neighboring 1,2-shift.

(b)

First a C3–H pair migrates to C2, leaving C3 cationic; then a C4–H pair migrates to C3, leaving C4 cationic.

(c)

No. Each step needs a viable pathway and rate. These secondary-to-secondary relocations are formal possibilities, not a prediction of favorable or dominant conversion.