Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Repair an unavailable proton donor in a basic mechanism
A mechanism in aqueous hydroxide uses H3O positive as the next proton donor without any acidic workup or other source. The intended next step is protonation of the shown alkoxide.
| Intermediate |
Why is invoking abundant hydronium inconsistent with the given strongly basic medium?
Which available species can provide a proton in the stated catalytic model?
Write the charge-balanced proton-transfer products.
Question 9 - Solution
Repair an unavailable proton donor in a basic mechanism
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
Hydronium is strongly depleted by hydroxide. Introducing it as an abundant independent reagent contradicts the medium unless a separate stage is specified.
(b)
Water can donate a proton to the alkoxide in the base-catalyzed hydration model.
(c)
HOCH2O negative plus H2O gives HOCH2OH plus OH negative. The net -1 charge and atom inventory are preserved.