Combining the Patterns of Arrow Pushing — Question 10

Section 6-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1349–1350

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Track isotope identity through catalyst regeneration

Use the same two-stage base-catalyzed hydration pattern: labeled hydroxide adds to formaldehyde, then the alkoxide is protonated by the indicated water. Ignore later oxygen exchange.

CH2^16O + ^18OH^- + H2^16O\text{CH2^{16}O + ^{18}OH^- + H2^{16}O}

  1. Which oxygen isotope enters as the incoming hydroxyl group?

  2. Which oxygen becomes the regenerated hydroxide?

  3. Explain how hydroxide catalytic function can be regenerated without retaining the original catalyst oxygen atom.

Question 10 - Solution

Track isotope identity through catalyst regeneration

Labeled hydrate

^16OH^-\text{^{16}OH^-}

(a)

The incoming hydroxyl contains oxygen-18; the original carbonyl oxygen-16 becomes the other hydroxyl after protonation.

(b)

The oxygen-16 atom of the proton-donating water becomes the regenerated hydroxide.

(c)

The hydroxide chemical species is replenished, but the original oxygen-18 atom is now in product. Isotope-resolved accounting distinguishes catalyst function from the identity of an individual atom.