Combining the Patterns of Arrow Pushing — Question 9

Section 6-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1347–1348

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Repair an unavailable proton donor in a basic mechanism

A mechanism in aqueous hydroxide uses H3O positive as the next proton donor without any acidic workup or other source. The intended next step is protonation of the shown alkoxide.

Intermediate
  1. Why is invoking abundant hydronium inconsistent with the given strongly basic medium?

  2. Which available species can provide a proton in the stated catalytic model?

  3. Write the charge-balanced proton-transfer products.

Question 9 - Solution

Repair an unavailable proton donor in a basic mechanism

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Hydronium is strongly depleted by hydroxide. Introducing it as an abundant independent reagent contradicts the medium unless a separate stage is specified.

(b)

Water can donate a proton to the alkoxide in the base-catalyzed hydration model.

(c)

HOCH2O negative plus H2O gives HOCH2OH plus OH negative. The net -1 charge and atom inventory are preserved.