Determining Which Mechanism Predominates — Question 4

Section 7-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1557–1558

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Use measured nucleophile order to resolve a secondary case

Substrate, medium, temperature and ionic strength are fixed. Nu is a good nucleophile with weak basicity; the substitution product is formed with inversion.

Secondary substrate

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the observed nucleophile order.

  2. Which simple substitution mechanism is favored by both observations?

  3. Why is the secondary label alone not decisive?

Question 4 - Solution

Use measured nucleophile order to resolve a secondary case

Secondary substrate

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The rate doubles with each doubling of Nu, indicating first order in Nu over this range.

(b)

SN2 is favored by the concentration dependence and inversion together.

(c)

Secondary substrates can follow different routes depending on the donor, solvent and conditions. Here the experimental evidence supplies what the structural label alone cannot.