Determining Which Mechanism Predominates — Question 5

Section 7-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1559–1560

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Recognize when ordinary substitution models do not apply

Consider only ordinary SN1/SN2 chemistry at saturated carbon, with no special catalysts or activating substituents.

A: vinyl chloride
B: chlorobenzene
  1. Why is A not an ordinary alkyl chloride substrate?

  2. Why is B not benzyl chloride?

  3. What is the justified conclusion about applying the usual decision chart?

Question 5 - Solution

Recognize when ordinary substitution models do not apply

A: vinyl chloride
B: chlorobenzene

(a)

A has chlorine directly on a vinylic sp2 carbon.

(b)

B has chlorine directly on the aromatic ring; there is no intervening benzylic CH2.

(c)

Neither is handled by the ordinary saturated-carbon SN1/SN2 chart. This does not imply that these compounds can never react by other mechanisms under other conditions.