Determining Which Mechanism Predominates — Question 6

Section 7-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1561–1562

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Predict neither fast pathway for a hindered primary halide

A weak neutral donor is used under mild conditions without special activation.

Neopentyl chloride
  1. What impedes ordinary SN2?

  2. What impedes direct ordinary SN1?

  3. Why is slow reaction a legitimate prediction?

Question 6 - Solution

Predict neither fast pathway for a hindered primary halide

Neopentyl chloride

(a)

The adjacent quaternary carbon creates severe steric hindrance near the primary reaction site; chloride is also less labile than iodide in many matched substitutions.

(b)

Direct ionization would generate a simple primary neopentyl cation, which is unfavorable.

(c)

Neither standard pathway is automatically efficient. One should not invent fast SN1 merely because SN2 is hindered; special rearrangement-assisted chemistry would require additional evidence or conditions.