Dimensional Analysis — Question 9

Section 1-6 · Chemistry pages 123–124

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Dimensions constrain a formula without fixing every constant

A proposed model has the form t=CLaDbt=C L^a D^b, where tt is time, LL is length, DD has units m2/s\mathrm{m^2/s}, and CC is dimensionless. Assume this power-law form contains no other dimensional quantities.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Determine aa and bb by matching length and time powers.

  2. For measured L=2.00L=2.00 mm and D=5.00×10−10m2/sD=5.00\times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m^2/s}, calculate t/Ct/C in s and h. Use exactly 1000 mm per m and 3600 s per h.

  3. Can dimensional analysis alone establish C=1C=1, or prove that the proposed model correctly describes a physical system?

Question 9 - Solution

Dimensions constrain a formula without fixing every constant

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Match independent dimensions

[LaDb]=lengtha+2btime−b.[L^aD^b]=\mathrm{length}^{a+2b}\,\mathrm{time}^{-b}.Matching time alone requires −b=1-b=1 and a+2b=0a+2b=0, givingb=−1,a=2,t=CL2D.\boxed{b=-1,\quad a=2,\quad t=C\frac{L^2}{D}}.These conclusions rely on the assumed form and dimensional inputs.

(b) Convert length before squaring

tC=(2.00×10−3m)25.00×10−10m2/s=8.00×103s.\frac{t}{C}=\frac{(2.00\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm m)^2}{5.00\times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m^2/s}}=\boxed{8.00\times10^3\ \mathrm s}.tC=8.00×103s1h3600s=2.22h.\frac{t}{C}=8.00\times10^3\ \mathrm s\,\frac{1\ \mathrm h}{3600\ \mathrm s}=\boxed{2.22\ \mathrm h}.The squared length units cancel the area units in DD.

(c) Recognize what dimensions cannot decide

No. Any dimensionless constant preserves unit consistency. Its value and the model's validity require further physical reasoning or measurements. The calculated quantity is t/Ct/C; it becomes a prediction for tt only when CC is specified.

Check and interpretation

Within this model, doubling LL multiplies tt by four at fixed CC and DD, while doubling DD halves it.