Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Dimensions constrain a formula without fixing every constant
A proposed model has the form , where is time, is length, has units , and is dimensionless. Assume this power-law form contains no other dimensional quantities.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Determine and by matching length and time powers.
For measured mm and , calculate in s and h. Use exactly 1000 mm per m and 3600 s per h.
Can dimensional analysis alone establish , or prove that the proposed model correctly describes a physical system?
Question 9 - Solution
Dimensions constrain a formula without fixing every constant
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Match independent dimensions
Matching time alone requires and , givingThese conclusions rely on the assumed form and dimensional inputs.
(b) Convert length before squaring
The squared length units cancel the area units in .
(c) Recognize what dimensions cannot decide
No. Any dimensionless constant preserves unit consistency. Its value and the model's validity require further physical reasoning or measurements. The calculated quantity is ; it becomes a prediction for only when is specified.
Check and interpretation
Within this model, doubling multiplies by four at fixed and , while doubling halves it.