Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Evaluate what a separation method actually separates
A homogeneous mixture contains volatile liquids X and Y. Under the operating conditions, vapor above the boiling mixture is richer in X than the liquid but still contains some Y. The vapor is condensed and collected. Neither component reacts or decomposes.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Name the separation method and state the property difference it uses. Is it a physical or chemical process?
Is the collected liquid necessarily pure X? Justify your conclusion using the given vapor composition.
Explain why ordinary filtration would not separate X and Y, and why repeated separation might improve enrichment without automatically proving purity.
Question 8 - Solution
Evaluate what a separation method actually separates
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Identify the method
This is distillation, exploiting different volatilities and a vapor composition different from the liquid composition. Vaporization and condensation preserve X and Y as substances, so the separation is physical.
(b) Track both components
No. Since the vapor contains Y, its collected condensate also contains Y under the stated conditions. It is enriched in X relative to the boiling liquid, but enrichment is not complete purification.
(c) Compare methods and limits
Ordinary filtration retains suspended particles; both components of this single liquid phase pass through. Further distillation may enrich X when vapor remains richer in X, but purity requires composition evidence and depends on separation behavior. Counting separation steps alone cannot establish purity.
Check and interpretation
The process changes proportions rather than chemical identities; the condensate remains a mixture in this collection.