Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Do not turn a tabulated atomic mass into a neutron count
A periodic-table entry for an element gives atomic number 17 and a tabulated atomic mass of 35.45 u. A particular atom is specified as chlorine-37. A student subtracts 17 from 35.45 to assign 18.45 neutrons to that atom.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the correct proton and neutron counts for chlorine-37.
Explain why the student's subtraction is inappropriate.
Does the mass number 37 assert that the atom's measured mass is exactly 37 atomic mass units?
Question 4 - Solution
Do not turn a tabulated atomic mass into a neutron count
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Chlorine has 17 protons. Chlorine-37 has mass number 37, so it has neutrons.
(b) Analysis
u is a tabulated average atomic mass for an isotopic composition, not the nucleon count of this particular atom. A neutron count is an integer determined here from the specified isotope.
(c) Conclusion
No. Mass number is an integer count. Actual atomic masses depend on constituent masses and binding effects and need not equal that integer in atomic mass units. Do not confuse the two quantities.
Check and interpretation
The isotope label supplies the needed mass number; rounding an average is not a replacement.