Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Order elements by proton count rather than average mass
Two supplied entries are argon: , average atomic mass 39.95 u; potassium: , average atomic mass 39.10 u. The modern periodic table is ordered by increasing atomic number.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which element comes first in atomic-number order?
Which would come first if these entries were sorted by the given average masses?
Explain why the disagreement is not a flaw in atomic-number ordering.
Question 6 - Solution
Order elements by proton count rather than average mass
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Argon comes first because .
(b) Analysis
A mass-only sort would put potassium first because .
(c) Conclusion
Atomic number tracks the number of protons and hence elemental identity. Average atomic masses also depend on isotope masses and abundances and need not increase strictly at every successive atomic number. The ordering rule is not average mass.
Check and interpretation
The two columns represent different quantities and answer different questions.